Hello dear
Welcome To Poor Gary's Pizza Of Eveleth
**About Poor Gary's Pizza Of Eveleth**Nestled in Eveleth, Minnesota, Poor Gary's Pizza Of Eveleth has made a triumphant return, rekindling fond memories for locals. Known for their mouthwatering pies, signature options like the Bacon Cheese Burger and Chicken Alfredo delight pizza enthusiasts. Catering to diverse cravings, their menu also features delectable appetizers, including crispy onion rings and cheesy curds. Customers rave about the warm ambiance and excellent service, transforming a simple meal into a memorable experience. With a commitment to quality and satisfaction, Poor Gary's is set to reclaim its place as a beloved staple in the community. Come savor the nostalgia and flavor!
Taste the best
Discover Our Menu
Onion Rings
US$7.00Taco
US$17.001meat & 1cheese
US$8.00
House
US$13.00Sausage & Pepperoni
Canadian Bacon
US$10.00
Sausage
US$10.00Pepperoni
US$10.00Cheese
US$9.00 About
Poor Gary's Pizza Of Eveleth
Welcome to Poor Gary's Pizza Of Eveleth, a beloved gem in the heart of Eveleth, Minnesota! Nestled at 420 Fayal Rd, this pizza destination has made a triumphant return to the local scene, much to the delight of pizza aficionados and nostalgic locals alike. Established once again under new ownership, Poor Gary's brings back cherished flavors that had been sorely missed during their hiatus. With a reputation for quality and a loyal following, this restaurant is rapidly becoming a staple for pizza lovers in the area.
The menu boasts a mouthwatering selection that caters to all taste buds. From the classic cheese pizza priced at just $10.75 to the loaded House Special at $17.00, there's an option for everyone. For those who crave something unique, the Bacon Cheese Burger and Chicken Alfredo pizzas are must-tries! Pair your pizza with delectable appetizers like crispy onion rings or savory cheese curds for a true culinary experience.
What truly sets Poor Gary's apart is the warmth of its community-centric spirit. Reviews from loyal patrons echo sentiments of nostalgia and excitement. Customers like Joe Peterson fondly recall their weekly visits from two decades ago, expressing joy over the revitalized atmosphere and delicious food. Jason Dall appreciates the outstanding service, highlighting the establishment's commitment to customer satisfaction, even when mistakes happen.
As the restaurant nimbly gets back on its feet, some may notice a busy vibe during peak hours—an indication of its increasing popularity. But don't let that deter you; the energy is infectious, and dining here feels like catching up with old friends over a meal that's genuinely made with love.
So, if you haven't yet tasted the magic of Poor Gary's, you're missing out on what many are calling the best pizza on the Range. It's more than just food; it's a cherished part of the community's fabric, ready to serve you slice after slice of delicious happiness.
For orders, you can reach them at (+1) 218-744-5508. Come rediscover the warmth and flavors of Poor Gary's Pizza Of Eveleth—your taste buds will thank you!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ They mixed up my order, but corrected and gave the other for free. Bad ass place. Definitely the place to get pizza now since Daves sux. ”
“ Poor Gary's was closed in Eveleth for a few years. Whoever bought it is doing a great job. I ordered a large pizza, and it was fantastic tasted just like Poor Gary's used to. So if you were a fan of Poor Gary's before, give the new owner a chance you won't be disappointed . ”
“ So glad to have Poor Gary's back in business. This was probably a weekly or more thing 20 years ago and when it closed it was truly sad for the area. I grabbed a sub there Friday and it was great and brought back the memories. It is nicely cleaned up inside from before (the ambiance/feel it used to have was great, but probably lost the pinky up crowd). It was busy and a little hectic, but I got there 30 min after opening on a Friday afternoon and they're still getting their feet on the ground... no complaint from me. I look forward to many awesome subs and pizzas! ”
“ Food is so good, glad there back! If you haven't tried them your missing out ”
“ Best pizza on the Range. Sorry Vi’s! ”
“ Great hidden gem in the quad city area on the Iron Range. Service was quick and friendly and the pizza was fantastic! I got the taco pizza and the crust was light fluffy and crunchy and the toppings were fresh. Great pizza sauce as well. Prices were reasonable. If you’re driving through the area this spot is well worth the detour! ”
“ The pizzas were perfect. Crisp but soft (?!) crust, the cheese was charred just enough, saucy without being too dangerous. I want these all the time. Should have asked for a side of ranch but they were still delicious without. We also had cheese curds and cinnamon-sugar bites with cream cheese frosting. Not a miss in the meal. ”
“ Recently reopened and better than ever. A good variety of pizzas, wings, subs, and various other options. Everything I've had from them is delicious. Very friendly staff, and a nice family friendly atmosphere inside. I definitely recommend it! ”